How to Create a Fair On-Call Rotation Schedule
An unfair on-call rotation is a fast track to team resentment and attrition. When some engineers consistently get the worst shifts or handle more incidents than others, morale suffers and good people leave. This guide shows you how to create on-call rotation schedules that are genuinely fair—and perceived as fair by your team.
Why Fairness Matters in On-Call
On-call duty is real work. It disrupts sleep, impacts personal time, and carries mental load. When that burden is distributed unfairly, problems compound:
- Burnout concentrates on specific individuals
- Resentment builds between team members
- Trust erodes in management decisions
- Retention suffers as overloaded people leave
Conversely, when on-call is fair, it becomes a manageable part of engineering life that teams accept as shared responsibility.
The Dimensions of On-Call Fairness
Fairness isn't just about equal calendar time. Consider these dimensions:
1. Time Distribution
Is the calendar time distributed evenly? Track hours or shifts per person per quarter.
2. Incident Load
Some shifts have more incidents than others. Track actual incidents handled, not just scheduled time.
3. Timing Quality
Weekend and holiday shifts are harder than weekday shifts. Are these distributed fairly?
4. Shift Patterns
Some people always get the shift right after a deployment (more incidents). Rotate starting days.
On-Call Rotation Schedule Templates
Here are proven rotation patterns that promote fairness:
Template 1: Simple Weekly Rotation
Best for: Teams of 4-8 engineers with similar experience levels
Week 1: Alice
Week 2: Bob
Week 3: Carol
Week 4: David
Week 5: Alice (cycle repeats)
Pros:
- Simple to understand and implement
- Equal time distribution
- Easy to plan personal time around
Cons:
- Doesn't account for incident volume variation
- Same person may always get holiday weeks
Fairness tip: Offset the start date each cycle so the same person doesn't always get the same calendar weeks.
Template 2: Rotating Day-of-Week Start
Best for: Teams wanting to distribute weekend coverage fairly
Instead of always starting on Monday, rotate the start day:
Cycle 1: Alice (Mon-Sun)
Cycle 2: Bob (Tue-Mon)
Cycle 3: Carol (Wed-Tue)
Cycle 4: David (Thu-Wed)
This ensures that weekend coverage rotates naturally through the team rather than always falling on the same person.
Template 3: Primary/Secondary Rotation
Best for: Teams wanting backup coverage and load distribution
Week 1: Primary: Alice, Secondary: Bob
Week 2: Primary: Bob, Secondary: Carol
Week 3: Primary: Carol, Secondary: David
Week 4: Primary: David, Secondary: Alice
Rules:
- Primary handles initial response
- Secondary provides backup if primary is unavailable or needs help
- Secondary becomes primary next week (always fresh context)
Fairness tip: Track both primary and secondary incident handling to ensure the load is actually distributed.
Template 4: Follow-the-Sun
Best for: Distributed teams across time zones
Americas (9 AM - 5 PM PT): US Team
EMEA (9 AM - 5 PM GMT): London Team
APAC (9 AM - 5 PM SGT): Singapore Team
Fairness principle: No one works outside their normal hours. Each region handles their timezone's business hours.
Partial coverage variation: If you don't have global coverage, combine this with an overnight secondary who can be escalated to.
Template 5: Weighted Rotation for Mixed Teams
Best for: Teams with varying experience levels or partial on-call participation
Not everyone may be ready for on-call. Weight participation:
Senior Engineers: Full rotation (every 4 weeks)
Mid-level Engineers: Full rotation (every 4 weeks)
Junior Engineers: Shadowing only (paired with senior)
As juniors gain experience, they enter the full rotation. This is fair because it accounts for capability, not just headcount.
Accounting for Special Circumstances
Holidays
Holidays are premium on-call time. Fair distribution approaches:
Option A: Volunteer First Ask for volunteers who prefer holiday shifts (some people like the quiet or want to swap for other time off). Fill remaining slots fairly.
Option B: Rotating Holiday Assignment Track who worked which holidays. Rotate so the same person doesn't work Thanksgiving two years in a row.
Option C: Holiday Premium Offer additional compensation (comp time or pay) for holiday shifts, making them less burdensome.
Vacations and Time Off
Fair on-call means respecting time off:
- Block vacation time from on-call scheduling in advance
- Require minimum notice (e.g., 2 weeks) to swap out of a shift
- Don't penalize people for taking vacation (don't give them back-to-back shifts before/after)
With OnCallManager, you can easily manage overrides and see upcoming schedules to avoid conflicts.
Parental Leave and Extended Absence
When someone is on extended leave:
- Remove them from the rotation entirely
- Don't "bank" shifts for them to make up later
- Gradually re-add them when they return
Fairness means recognizing that life circumstances vary.
Measuring and Improving Fairness
Metrics to Track
| Metric | What It Measures | Fair Target |
|---|---|---|
| Shifts per person per quarter | Time distribution | Within 10% of average |
| Incidents per person per quarter | Actual workload | Within 20% of average |
| Weekend shifts per person | Off-hours burden | Equal count |
| Page response time by person | Engagement level | Consistent across team |
Quarterly Fairness Review
Every quarter, review on-call distribution:
- Pull the data - Shifts worked, incidents handled, response times
- Identify imbalances - Who's over/under on any metric?
- Adjust the schedule - Give relief to overloaded members
- Discuss as a team - Transparency builds trust
Team Feedback
Numbers don't tell the whole story. Ask your team:
- "Do you feel on-call is distributed fairly?"
- "What would make on-call feel more fair?"
- "Are there hidden burdens we're not tracking?"
Sometimes fairness issues are about perception as much as reality. Address both.
Common Fairness Anti-Patterns
"The Hero Trap"
One person is "the expert" who gets called for everything. This concentrates load unfairly and creates a single point of failure.
Fix: Document knowledge, cross-train, and let the expert escalate to others.
"New People Don't Do On-Call"
Protecting new hires for too long shifts burden to tenured team members.
Fix: Shadow period (2-4 weeks), then full rotation participation with clear escalation path.
"Same Shift Every Time"
Algorithms that always assign the same time slot to the same person create invisible unfairness.
Fix: Rotate starting days and audit time-of-day distribution.
"Invisible Second Shifts"
The primary on-call is tracked, but backup or escalation handling isn't.
Fix: Track all incident response participation, not just primary.
Implementing Fair Rotations with Tools
What to Look for in On-Call Software
Fair rotations require tooling that supports:
- Automatic rotation scheduling - Reduces manual bias
- Override and swap management - Handles exceptions fairly
- Visibility into schedule - Everyone can see what's coming
- Historical tracking - Data for fairness reviews
OnCallManager Approach
OnCallManager helps maintain fair rotations by:
- Automatic rotation - Cycles through team members evenly
- Visual schedule preview - See upcoming on-call assignments
- Easy overrides - Swap shifts when needed, tracked automatically
- Slack visibility - Everyone can see who's on-call right now
The transparency of Slack-native scheduling means fairness issues are visible to the whole team, not hidden in a separate tool.
Building Team Buy-In
A technically fair schedule isn't enough—your team needs to believe it's fair.
Involve the Team in Design
Let the team vote on rotation pattern, shift length, and escalation policies. Ownership increases acceptance.
Publish the Rules
Document how on-call scheduling works and make it accessible. "The algorithm decides" isn't satisfying; "Here are the rules" is.
Act on Feedback
When someone raises a fairness concern, investigate it seriously. Even if the data shows fairness, acknowledge the concern and explain the reasoning.
Compensate Appropriately
Fair on-call isn't just about distribution—it's about recognition. Ensure on-call is compensated (time, money, or both).
Conclusion
Fair on-call rotation isn't just a nice-to-have—it's essential for sustainable operations. By considering all dimensions of fairness (time, incidents, timing, patterns), using appropriate templates, and measuring outcomes, you can build an on-call program your team trusts.
Remember:
- Track not just scheduled time, but actual incident workload
- Rotate special circumstances (weekends, holidays) explicitly
- Review and adjust quarterly with team input
- Be transparent about how scheduling decisions are made
With the right approach and tools like OnCallManager, on-call becomes a shared responsibility that doesn't burden any individual unfairly.
Ready to build fairer rotations? Add OnCallManager to Slack and start managing on-call schedules with full visibility for your team.
Related reading: